Fabricated Visuals and Defamation: Indian Media Failures During Operation Sindoor
Global Voices
- During the 2025 'Operation Sindoor' conflict, major Indian news channels broadcast fabricated war reports, repurposed archival footage, and falsely identified deceased civilians as terrorists.
- Formal complaints were filed by organizations like Citizens for Justice and Peace (CJP), citing systematic violations of broadcasting standards.
- A Poonch district court ordered a First Information Report (FIR) against media outlets for defamation and public mischief.
The Defamation of Maulana Qari Mohammad Iqbal
- On May 7, 2025, religious teacher Maulana Qari Mohammad Iqbal was killed by artillery fire in Poonch.
- News18 MP Chhattisgarh, Republic World, and Zee News falsely labeled him a 'top Lashkar-e-Taiba commander' and 'terrorist' involved in the Pulwama attack.
- Local police confirmed Iqbal had no militant links. His family is pursuing a 50 million INR defamation lawsuit.
- Sub-Judge Shafeeq Ahmed ruled that such reporting is not a mere lapse but a severe violation, noting that apologies do not exempt outlets from legal consequences.
Fabricated Combat Footage
- Hindi news channel Aaj Tak repeatedly aired old, unrelated footage as 'live combat' from the India-Pakistan conflict.
- One segment claimed to show Indian strikes in Pakistan, but was actually footage of Israeli airstrikes in Gaza from 2023.
- Another segment purported to show a Pakistani air attack intercepted in Rajasthan; it was four-year-old footage of Israel’s Iron Dome system.
Systemic Misinformation
- A June 2025 Washington Post investigation identified a pattern of 'fiction-writing' across major networks including NDTV, Times Now, and India TV.
- Claims included the surrender of the Pakistani PM and the destruction of Karachi, none of which were confirmed.
- Misinformation was reportedly fueled by unverified 'leaks' from WhatsApp groups and the use of retired military pundits to validate falsehoods as a psychological 'war tactic'.